Quakers in Criminal Justice

Report on Quakers in Criminal Justice Conference 2008
From Faith into Action

This was the title of the 2008 QICJ conference, which was held 22—24 February at the Quaker Study Centre, Woodbrooke, Birmingham. Its theme was linked to the 2007 Yearly Meeting Epistle:

Before we act it is important to look within and examine our motivation. Initially, we may be prompted by anger, guilt or fear – we need help to transform these into love. The road of transformation is not easy; worship and discipleship will show us the way. Only then will we become truly open to the guidance of the Spirit and our work will become love in action... Through quiet, listening prayer we can discover what is required of us.

Britain Yearly Meeting epistle 2007

Our first speaker was Juliet Lyon, Director of the Prison Reform Trust... “The Challenge Facing Us”. She is well known in the media and has many discussions with Government Ministers and told us that all projections to the future see the prison population continuing to increase. There is no magic cut-off point and numbers could climb over the 100,000 mark. Juliet described the situation as like building an extra lane for a motorway, which, as soon as it is completed, is congested with cars — the same goes for prisons. On the day she spoke there were 82,068 in custody, the estate capacity being 81,972. There were 92 suicides last year and with the overcrowding causing frequent prisoner moves, the “first night experience” (when prisoners are most vulnerable) becomes more frequent too. This level of incarceration appears not to prevent re-offending as 64% of adult prisoners are reconvicted of a criminal offence within two years. This rises to 74% of young offenders and a staggering 84% of children. The “titan” prisons envisaged by the present Home Secretary, to be built at a cost of £3 billion, will provide another 9000 places. No one doubts that enough men, women and children will be found to fill them. Does this represent value for money? Prison is really not working.

The cost to society in every way is huge. Seven per cent of schoolchildren will experience having a parent in prison this year — more than will experience divorce. One in four men and half of all women on remand receive no visits from their family, though a remand prisoner is entitled to a visitor every day. We have more Lifers than France, Germany, Turkey and the Russian Federation added together, and many are serving over their tariff, there is such reluctance to release them.

Mike Rose of the St Giles Trust spoke about “Examples of Resourceful Thinking”. He stressed that the Prison Service is not making enough use of the main resource it had — the prisoners. It costs on average £45,000 p.a. to keep a person in prison. If on release they have accommodation and a job, then there is far less chance of re-offending. St Giles trains people who have been in prison to “Meet & Greet” those being released. They also work inside prisons, providing training in “Information and Guidance” to NVQ Level 3, which is equivalent to two A Levels. This “Peer Advice Project” has become well respected. The charity is also involved in recruiting ex-offenders to deliver services to the community. The organisation is currently only in the South of England, but is now going national.

Marina Cantacuzione told us of the Forgiveness Project. Around the room was a wonderful exhibition of photographs and text on the theme of forgiveness. (These appear in Marina's book, The F Word: Images of Forgiveness, which was reviewed in a previous newsletter.) The project was launched in 2004 with support from the late Anita Roddick, owner of “Body Shop”. The purpose of the project is to change opinions, to demonstrate that there are alternatives to revenge. The exhibits told a number of individual stories of how victims and perpetrators had come to terms with horrendous crimes. Forgiveness is not conditional on remorse, but it is a wise choice both emotionally, physically and spiritually. It releases the victim from the grip of the perpetrator, enabling them to take back the power they had lost through being victimised. “Forgiveness is giving up all hope of a better past.” Marina later ran two workshops so that Friends could explore the subject in more depth.

Mike Jackson also ran workshops describing the Camden Garden Centre, a small and successful business able to offer a two-year contract to disadvantaged people, including ex-offenders. They do a Level 2 NVQ, learn to drive free of charge, and get certificates in First Aid and fork lift truck driving. The project was established in the early '80s. A link with the Probation Service gives the participants a really good start on the way to the world of work. Many offenders come from chaotic backgrounds, have little or no self-esteem, and no support. Working in disciplined surroundings with set boundaries helps to give shape to their lives. They learn too how to sort out their differences without resort to verbal or physical violence. More information is available on www.camdenqardencentre.co.uk.

A third choice for the workshop sessions was provided by Rosie Aubrey, on the Alternatives to Violence Project. Historically, AVP began when a number of Lifers in a New York prison appealed to Quakers to help them change their attitudes and so avoid getting in trouble again. Facilitators and participants are always volunteers. In recent years AVP has been invited to help organisations such as MIND and Sure Start. It aims to build self-esteem, ability to communicate, develop trust and the ability to solve problems; overall, to promote a sense of community. AVP builds on people's previous experiences, and recognizes that different people react in various ways to the challenges that face them. It also aims to train suitable participants as future facilitators, which is valuable in a prison setting, as these facilitators will have street cred. During 2007, 168 people took part in AVP courses in five British prisons.

Sunday morning started with a wonderfully deep Meeting for Worship with profound ministry. The final speaker was Marian Liebmann: “Action — The Spiritual Dimension”. After giving a resume of the weekend, she pointed to the signs of hope. The success of Circles of Support and Accountability, going national this year, and the increasing acceptance of Restorative Justice practices, are two of these. We would need courage as well as love to take things forward. She asked us to address three questions: What can I do in my life on my own? What can I do with others? What can we do in the wider society? A closing discussion, along lines suggested by Tim Newell, started our consideration of these things.

We stand at a grim moment in the history of criminal justice in Britain, when it seems to many of us that those in charge of the system have lost all moral credibility. But anyone who attended the weekend at Woodbrooke would take heart: there are many hopeful signs.

Report written by several of those attending.